TheirDesk

A read, in full

This is what twenty-four dollars buys

Not a description of it. The whole thing, on someone else’s essay, free and without an account. Yours would look like this, about your words.

Common App · Personal growth

Hillman Hardware, fifteen hours a week

A real read of an essay we wrote, kept here so you can see one without paying. Yours is read the same way.

Read a sample read · 604 words · limit 650

This will not hurt your file. It is clean, it is inside the limit, and the paint counter paragraph is written by somebody who has actually stood behind one: the fraction of an ounce, the ninety-second shaker, the formula taped inside the lid. Everything around that paragraph is in a register anyone could have used about any job, and by the second list of three I have stopped hearing you. Tomorrow I will remember a hardware store, and not you.

These notes are strict because the standard is. Nothing here says you cannot clear it.

0

Hurts

30

Hurts a little

50

Neutral

70

Helps

85

Rare

below here, an admissions reader notices

Where the marks fall, from the first word to the last

0604 words

13 marks · first at word 1 of 604 · longest unmarked run 168 words, paragraphs 2–3

52/100

Neutral

Sample read · how the read is made

Live reads keep a mark only when at least two readers made it independently.

Scores use the median of each dimension from the readers that completed the read.

The total is arithmetic: five readings, ten points each, doubled.

Not scored: grammar, spelling, formatting.

Read the full rubric →

The first thing

Let the paint counter run the essay

Six paragraphs, one of them alive. The reader can see, hear and count the tint machine paragraph, and it is the only place in the essay that could not have been written about some other job by some other student. The five paragraphs around it explain what that paragraph already proves, and every explanation gives back ground the paragraph won. A reader thirty-eight essays into the night keeps the counter and forgets the lessons.

How

Go paragraph by paragraph and ask what object is in each one. Where the answer is nothing, either find the shift that produced the claim or drop the claim. Your first and fifth paragraphs make the same argument in the same three-part shape, so ask which single sentence in each one has a thing in it and let the rest of both go. Then ask what has happened at that counter that you have not told anyone, and whether it belongs where the first list currently sits.

This is where to start, not the whole job. There are 9 other marks below.

The draft, marked

0 of 13 addressed

  • Keep
  • Not yours
  • Not working
  • Not here
  • 10 to fix · 3 to keep

I have worked at Hillman Hardware since the summer before my junior year, about fifteen hours a week during the school year and more in the summer. It is not an exciting job. I stock shelves, cut keys, break down cardboard, and mix paint. But over two years it has taught me a lot about responsibility, patience, and how to talk to people who are not my age, and I think those are lessons that will matter to me in college.

Before I started, I do not think I really understood what it means to be depended on. School has deadlines, but a deadline is mostly between you and a teacher. At work, if I am late, someone else has to cover the register, and if I do a job carelessly, a customer drives home with the wrong thing. Balancing homework and shifts was difficult at first. I close on Thursdays and work eight to four on Saturdays, which is most of the weekend my friends have. Many students work while they are in school, and I have a lot more respect for all of them now.

The paint counter is the part of the store I know best. The tint machine dispenses colorant in increments of one three-hundred-eighty-fourth of an ounce, and the shaker runs for ninety seconds, long enough that the whole counter hums and the loose keys in my apron buzz against each other. Last October Mr. Petrosyan came in with a piece of drywall about the size of a playing card, broken out of his own hallway with a screwdriver, because his wife had picked the color in 1998 and he did not want to repaint the whole hallway to fix one patch. I put the chip in the scanner. It read back as a warm gray, and I mixed a quart, and he pried the lid off in the parking lot to check it against the piece in the sunlight. He came back in and said, "That's it. Don't lose that number." I wrote the formula on the back of his receipt and taped a second copy inside the lid.

Most of my shifts are not like that one. Most of the time I am answering the same questions about furnace filters or telling somebody which aisle the batteries are in. But I started to notice that a lot of customers come in a little stressed, because something in their house is broken and they do not know how to fix it. Learning to slow down and actually listen to what a person was describing, instead of guessing halfway through, made me better at my job, and I think it made me better in group projects at school too.

Working at the hardware store taught me three things. It taught me that being reliable is a skill you build by showing up, not a personality trait you either have or do not have. It taught me that adults are usually willing to explain something to you if you admit you do not know it. And it taught me that careful work matters even when nobody is watching you do it, because a gallon mixed wrong does not show up until it is already on somebody's wall.

I am not planning a career in hardware. I want to study mechanical engineering, and eventually I would like to design things that other people have to maintain. But I believe the habits I built behind that counter will serve me in a college classroom and in whatever I do afterward. I am grateful for a job that most people would call ordinary.

00 / 13

I have worked at Hillman… ] résumé in prose

This is your activity list with the abbreviations removed. A reader has already seen these hours on another page, and the first sentence of an essay is the one place they cannot skip.

But over two years it… ] telling, not showing

Three abstract nouns land before a single object does. You already wrote a concrete sentence about this job further down the page, and the reader wants it in the position where they decide whether to keep reading.

Shown edit3 of 6 left

But over two years it has taught me to mix a quart of warm gray from a piece of drywall the size of a playing card.

A demonstration, not your sentence. It uses only what is already in your draft.

Many students work while they… ] vague

Here the essay steps back and speaks for a category. A reader believes one person at one register, and nobody else working those jobs is on this page.

The tint machine dispenses colorant… ] keep this

A fraction of an ounce, ninety seconds, keys buzzing in an apron. A reader notices because these are numbers only somebody who ran the machine would carry, and they buy trust for everything after them.

He came back in and… ] keep this

Two lines of real speech, contractions and all, from a man who checked his quart against the sunlight first. It is the only place in the essay where anybody besides you talks.

Most of my shifts are… ] cut

You apologize for the only paragraph a reader will remember, then spend a paragraph proving the apology. Losing this sentence costs the essay nothing.

and I think it made… ] vague

The transfer to school arrives as a claim with no scene under it. Either name the project and what you did differently inside it, or let the counter carry the point alone.

Working at the hardware store… ] telling, not showing

Numbering the lessons is the moment the essay stops noticing and starts concluding. The best sentence in this paragraph is its last one, and a reader can count to three without being told to.

Shown edit3 of 6 left

A gallon mixed wrong does not show up until it is already on somebody's wall.

A demonstration, not your sentence. It uses only what is already in your draft.

It taught me that being… ] stock phrase

A sentence anyone could write about any job. Nothing in it came from Hillman, and it would sit unchanged in an essay about a job you never worked.

It taught me that adults… ] vague

True of adults everywhere, which is why it is not evidence. Which adult, on which shift, explained what to you after you admitted you did not know it?

I want to study mechanical… ] keep this

The second-best line you have, and the only place where the job and the major touch. A reader notices because it is a thought about maintenance that two years behind a counter would produce and a list of virtues would not.

But I believe the habits… ] vague

The habits are named as habits and then left abstract, three paragraphs after you showed me one being built. End the sentence on something a reader can point at.

Shown edit3 of 6 left

But I built those habits when I taped a second copy of the formula inside the lid.

A demonstration, not your sentence. It uses only what is already in your draft.

I am grateful for a… ] telling, not showing

The closing line instructs me how to regard the job rather than leaving me at the counter with you. This is where a reader shuts the file, and right now it shuts on a summary.

What held

"the shaker runs for ninety seconds, long enough that the whole counter hums and the loose keys in my apron buzz against each other" — you counted, and a reader can hear the store.

"design things that other people have to maintain" is the one sentence that shows what two years behind a counter did to the way you think.

The five readings

Ten points each, added and doubled. That is the whole of the number at the top of this page.

0510

Opening

Does the first paragraph earn the second?

5

2 marks

Your first sentence is the activity list with the abbreviations taken out, and your fourth hands me three abstract nouns before I have watched you do anything. I keep going because the paragraph is short, not because it earned the next one.

Specificity

Can the reader see, hear, or count anything?

6

2 marks

One paragraph can be seen, heard and counted: a fraction of an ounce, ninety seconds, a chip of drywall the size of a playing card. Outside it the objects thin out to furnace filters and batteries in passing, and the one that lands, a gallon already on somebody's wall, is buried in the paragraph that explains instead of shows.

Voice

Does it sound like one seventeen-year-old, not a template?

5

2 marks

At the paint counter you sound like a person. Everywhere else you sound like somebody writing an essay about a job rather than somebody who has one, and the two registers sit side by side without mixing.

Reflection

Does the essay know what its story means, without announcing it?

5

4 marks

You tell me what the job taught you three separate times, in the same shape each time. The essay knows what it means and will not let me arrive there myself. The line that actually thinks, about designing things other people have to maintain, is buried in the last paragraph.

Prompt & length

Does it answer the prompt inside the limit, and end on an image?

5

3 marks

You answer the prompt inside the limit and the growth is real. The last sentence tells me how to regard the job instead of leaving me somewhere, so the essay closes on a summary rather than on the counter.

What I’d ask you

  1. What happens at that counter when somebody brings back a gallon that was mixed wrong?
  2. What is the first thing you ever mixed badly at that counter?
  3. You close on Thursdays. What is the last thing you do before you lock the door?
  4. What did you say to Mr. Petrosyan when he came back in holding the drywall?
  5. What is behind the paint counter that a customer standing on the other side never sees?

The checks

Prompt

answered

You name the growth and stay inside 650 words. It arrives as a numbered list in the fifth paragraph rather than as the moment that caused it, so the realization is reported to me instead of reached in front of me.

Length

604 / 650

604 of 650 words.

Ending

ends on a statement

The last sentence restates. Most essays lose their last goodwill here.

Read on
a sample read
Readers
Sample read
Agreement
a mark is shown only where at least two readers marked the same words
Scores
the median per dimension, summed, doubled
Shown edits
3 used, 3 left, for this essay's whole life
Draft
604 words of 650 · Common App Personal growth
Rubric
v1 — read the full rubric →
Not scored
grammar, spelling, formatting

This read marks and asks. It does not write.

This read judged the draft you pasted. It did not see your transcript, your other essays, or the school you are sending this to. It is not a prediction of any admission decision.

Now do it to yours

One essay, as many drafts as you send, and the score moves or it does not. Paste the whole thing, not a paragraph. The reader needs the ending to judge the beginning.